The Williams family from Brighton, Melbourne, bought a Berawa villa for AUD 320K in 2021. What followed was a costly lesson in Bali villa investment returns.

"We signed with the developer's management company," recalls Sarah. "They charged 25% of gross rental. Our villa was occupied 180 nights — a neighbour had 280."

The Search and Purchase

The family inspected 20+ villas and chose a developer-recommended agent in Berawa. The villa was leasehold (25 years) for AUD 320K. Their Bali villa investment returns projection showed 11.5% net at 70% occupancy.

"The first red flag was the management report," Sarah says. "Monthly statements showed cleaning costs twice our neighbour's."

Year One: AUD 60K Lost

The developer's management company charged 25% of gross revenue — well above the 15-20% market rate. Cleaning costs were AUD 20.5K, utilities AUD 6K, and tax AUD 1.2K. Their neighbour with identical villa and independent management paid AUD 8K less in fees for 55% more revenue. The difference in Bali villa investment returns was AUD 30K/year in lost potential.

Gross: AUD 54K. Net: AUD 12.8K (4% yield) — their neighbour generated 55% more. The difference in Bali villa investment returns was occupancy: 180 vs 280 nights. The manager had no booking system and responded within 48 hours. The villa was losing AUD 30K/year in potential income.

The Recovery

After terminating the developer contract (AUD 5K exit fee), the Williams family hired an independent manager recommended by other Australian owners. The new manager reduced fees to 18%, implemented multi-platform channel management, and responded to guest inquiries within 2 hours instead of 48. Their Bali villa investment returns improved immediately as occupancy jumped 44%.

They terminated the contract (AUD 5K exit fee) and hired an independent manager who reduced fees to 18%, implemented channel management, and responded within 2 hours — transforming their Bali villa investment returns. Occupancy increased from 180 to 260 nights within 3 months. Guest ratings returned to 4.7.

Results: From 4% to 16% Net Yield

Year	Gross Rental	Net Return	Net Yield	Occupancy
2022-2023	$54,000	$12,800	4%	180 nights
2024	$78,000	$42,460	13.3%	260 nights
2025	$84,000	$47,880	15%	260+ nights
2026	$90,000	$51,800	16.2%	270+ nights

Five-year net rental income: AUD 155K (AUD 95K after the year-one loss). Property appreciated to AUD 400K. They invested AUD 12K in pool resurfacing in 2025, increasing rates from AUD 180 to 220 and improving Bali villa investment returns by AUD 10.4K/year — 87% annual return.

What We'd Do Differently

Interview 3+ management companies and ask for Australian owner references
Request itemised monthly statements with receipts
Install channel manager showing live booking data
Visit the property quarterly in the first year
Verify all expenses against market rates

Book a personalised due diligence consultation with Pertama Property's investment team to learn how families achieve 15%+ Bali villa investment returns.

For verified data: ATO foreign investment rules for property investors, BKPM Indonesia investment regulations, and Smartraveller Indonesia travel advice.

Read our related guides: Self-Manage vs PM: Cost Comparison, Sell Your Bali Villa: Complete Guide, and Bali Villa Renovation ROI: Data Analysis.

PERTAMA PROPERTYPERTAMA PROPERTY

PERTAMA PROPERTY

PERTAMA PROPERTY
PERTAMA PROPERTY